Baylor Alumni
Spring 2010
 
Winter 2010
 
 
Fall 2009
 
 
Summer 2009
 
 
Spring 2009
 
 
Winter 2009
 
 
Baylor Alumni

National Spotlight

By Terri Jo Ryan

The startling news that more Americans apparently believe in the reality of hell (73 percent) than in heaven (63 percent) was just one of many surprising conclusions reached this fall in What Americans Really Believe.

The book--released by Baylor University's Institute for Studies of Religion under lead author Rodney Stark with eighteen colleagues--debuted in September 2008 at the annual conference of the Religion Newswriters of America.

The book compiles the finding of surveys of more than sixteen hundred English-speaking adults in autumn 2007 conducted by The Gallup Organization--which also ran a 2005 poll for Baylor. The Baylor surveys started in 2005 and will be conducted every two years through at least 2018, researchers noted. The questionnaire used for the study was labeled "The Values and Beliefs of the American Public: A National Study," and those taking the survey did not know it was for Baylor.

The book consists of twenty-three chapters with eighty annotated and narrated tables, and it covers nearly every aspect of spiritual expression in the United States. In addition to presenting the current data, the book also compares data based on research stretching back, in some cases, forty to sixty years ago.

For example, the book points out that, in asking "Do Americans believe in life after death?" a 1957 Gallup poll found that 74 percent said yes. A 1964 study conducted by Stark found 79 percent agreeing that existence endures.

In Baylor's 2005 study, that number had increased to 84 percent--with women, African-Americans, non-college educated people, Southerners, and Republicans all more likely to believe in something beyond the grave.

So, who is headed to the realm of the eternal, according to the newest survey? Researchers found that few Americans think heaven is very exclusive, although fewer than 30 percent think that even the irreligious will get entry into heaven.

Even the large numbers of people who offered "no opinion" on who will or will not be admitted (between 21 and 39 percent, according to religious identification) are a far cry from the old days, Stark said. Earlier generations of Americans held very strong views that "narrow was the way" to the Pearly Gates. For example, the 1954 Gallup poll noted that slightly more than half of Americans held that people who did not claim the lordship of Jesus Christ could not be saved. Researchers in 2007 did not think to ask who is going to hell. "Maybe next time,” Stark said.

The national media, in reporting some of the results of the most recent Baylor study, found and reported many tantalizing items:
  • 20 percent of Americans have said they heard the voice of God speaking to them.
  • 44 percent said they felt "called by God" to do something.
  • 55 percent said they felt that they had been protected from harm by an angel.
  • 23 percent said they had witnessed a miraculous healing.
  • 16 percent said they themselves had experienced a miraculous healing.
  • 8 percent said they spoke or prayed in tongues.
Spiritual and mystical experiences have been an overlooked aspect of national religious life, said Stark, a sociology professor at Baylor. The topic has been neglected by many researchers and ignored by even leading clerics and seminary scholars.

But these kinds of spiritual experiences are so fundamental to American faith life that two-thirds of those surveyed reported having at least one such happening in their lives--results that Stark said "absolutely knocked me down."

Other findings of the Baylor biennial study of faith included:
  • Congregants find that megachurches (defined as having at least 1,000 members) offer more personal worship and a greater sense of communion than smaller churches--challenging the conventional wisdom that these large congregations are too huge to provide a meaningful religious experience.
  • Megachurch members were twice as likely to have close, personal friends in their congregation as members of small churches. These believers also displayed a higher level of personal commitment to their church, such as attending services and tithing more often than small-church members.
  • The more literally one reads the Bible, the less likely a white voter is willing to cast his or her ballot for a racial minority. Additionally, members of churches that are entirely white are more than two times less likely to vote for a non-white candidate.
One aspect of the Baylor report that garnered little coverage in the mainstream media, but much commenting in the blogosphere, were the findings about atheists, agnostics, the irreligious, and the merely unchurched. According to the study, 31 percent of people who never attend worship services expressed strong belief in such things as Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster, advanced civilizations like Atlantis, haunted houses, and the possibility of communicating with the dead. Only 8 percent of people who attend a house of worship more than once a week shared similar beliefs. "Sunday school seems to innoculate you against such nonsense," Stark said.

Stark said that the current group of findings highlights "The Godless revolution that never happened." Although the New Atheist movement in recent years--led by writers Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and Sam Harris--has generated a lot of buzz on the topic, the numbers don't show any dramatic increase in their adherents.

The percentage of Americans who say they do not believe in God has consistently hovered around 4 percent for more than sixty years, Baylor researchers found. It doesn't grow, Stark said, because irreligiosity is not transmitted from parent to child: most children from such households grow up to join churches, often conservative ones.

Who are these atheists? Stark said they are overwhelming white, male, liberal ex-protestants of any age who have attended college. Stark described them as "a whole group of little PhDs running around saying 'God is dead.' Their books make them sound desperate, and they should be."



Baylor Alumni Site Map  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms & Conditions